Check out our new DOG WALKING, and pet/house sitting services in Victoria BC!!!  

LIKE us AT Facebook!  Share and see great dog photos, tips and toy advice!

Dry Dog Food Comparison

Our dry dog food comparison page is for all those who want to compare dog foods and dog food ratings by looking at the dog food ingredients for one, and price for another.

If you really want to do an indepth comparison of dog food. Petsumer Report does the hard research into which companies use good quality human-grade food, leaving you with the best information and each dog food with a rating up to 5 paws!


Before you buy any dog food for your pet, it will be essential that you know what is the best nutrition for your dogs health. This can be done by comparing dog food ingredients and look at Dog Food Ratings.

If you are feeding your dog healthy food, they'll feel great, look great and live longer. Plus it will save on vet bills and health for your dog.


Good dog food will promote longevity, vitality, healthy coat, clear eyes, regular bowel movements, healthy teeth and clean breath.  This is why it's important to compare dog foods and taking the time to read our dry dog food comparison to fully understand what they are eating.


While many foods may seem like the best option based on packaging promises, we will show you what to look for - from good and bad ingredients when doing a dry dog food comparison.  So you can choose which is the healthiest option for your dog.


Plus you can also go to Petsumer Report where they rate dog foods with 1 to 5 paws. Saving you time, or as an addition to your own research.

Many manufactured dog foods (canned OR dry) contain cheap 'filler' / by-products that are less than desirable for your pet.  


What works for me, is that I give my doggies my home-made food 1-3 times a week, depending on the time availability that I have to make the food.   I feed my home-made softer food, followed by a top quality dry kibble for teeth cleaning.  This is a great compromise for a working owner who doesn't have the time to make their own dog food.  Check out my dog food recipe.


Good quality dry dog food contains essential vitamins, and they help to clean their teeth too!


This page is meant to help you select and do your own dry dog food comparison, fashioned to your dogs dietary needs.



Find Out The Main Ingredients Of The Dog Food

Note:  Remember when choosing dog food, the most expensive is not necessarily the best, and the worst is not necessarily the cheapest.  A dog food that we use is is very reasonably priced, and very healthy.  Our dog Patches has a very sensitive stomach and can only handle another brand.


We start out our dry dog food comparison by looking at the first ingredient.


1)  Protein - The first ingredient should be a meat protein.  

Protein is important for muscle repair and long lasting energy.

Preferably a smaller animal such that they would eat in the wild - such as lamb, or chicken, NOT beef.  Beef is ok in smaller amounts ideally, but not as the first ingredient.

Protein amounts should be 22-24%, although this percent will depend on your dogs age and any medical conditions such as diabetes or kidney problems etc.


Protein from quality meat ingredients is the single most important part of your dog's diet. 


An important part of our dry dog food comparison to remember is that the first ingredient listed should be a specified meat meal, or a fresh meat type (ex.  Lamb), followed by a meat meal (ex. Lamb meal).


Lamb OR Lamb Meal?

Some people prefer to not feed their dog a meat meal thinking that it's a by-product.  But from experience, I've found that I've raised healthy long-living dogs, and the first ingredinet was lamb meal.

Meat sources in meal form are not bad for the dog food, but only if derived from a specified type of animal. You see meat meal consists of meat and skin, and possibly some bones, but nothing else.

Good animal proteins are listed in best to worst:

  • Lamb
  • Lamb Meal
  • Chicken
  • Chicken meal
  • Turkey
  • Turkey meal
  • Herring
  • Herring meal
  • Duck
  • Duck meal
  • Beef
  • Beef meal
  • Eggs
  • Pea Protein


Here are the protein ingredients you should avoid:

  • All generic meat ingredients that do not list a species
  • Byproducts meals (Byproducts consist of anything but the quality cuts of meat and is not fit for human consumption).
  • Corn gluten or soybean meal as the main ingredient.



2) Carbohydrate - The next non-meat ingredient should be a carbohydrate.   Carbohydrates can originate from grains like barley, rice, wheat, oats and corn, but also alternative sources like potatoes, sweet potatoes, peas or tapioca.


Note:  Many dog foods have corn, corn meal, corn gluten as the first ingredient.  Just like many human foods that add corn as a filler, it is not nutritious and you do not want it to be a main ingredient.



  • The tolerance to carbohydrates depends on the dog and it's health, because many dogs need a grain free diet.



    The type of carbohydrate is important. Here are the carbohydrate ingredients that are good for dog food in our dry dog food comparison (in order of most digestible):
  • Rice
  • Potatoes
  • Sweet potatos
  • Peas
  • Beet Pulp
  • Oats
  • Barley
  • Millet
  • Whole ground grains


Here are the carbohydrate ingredients you should avoid:

  • Corn gluten meal
  • Wheat
  • Potato product fragments
  • Mill of any kind
  • Unspecified grain sources like grain fermentation solubles
  • and cereal food fines


3) Fats And Oils - A good percent of fat is 14% for a moderately active dog.  If your dog is less active or has a fat intolerance, this amount should be lower.


A dog's skin and coat will remain healthy with some fats and oils in ther dog food. Proper brain development is helped by fats and oils in their diet.


Fats and oils must be specifically named and of high nutrition.

Some good ones are:

  • chicken fat
  • canola oil
  • sunflower oil
  • herring oil
  • flax oil.


Here are the fats and oils you need to avoid when buying dog food:

  • mineral oil
  • animal fat (nondescriptive)
  • poultry fat (nondescriptive)
  • generic fish oil
  • vegetable oil


Note: Dogs will love lard and beef tallow, but these are high in saturated fats and low in fatty acids (which are needed for a good diet).





4)  Dietary Supplements

Additional supplements such as vitamins and minerals are added to the food to give an overall healthier food with all essential nutrients for good health.  


The food you choose needs to have a "Guaranteed Analysis" to show nutrient amoutns of:

  • crude protein, 
  • crude fat, 
  • crude fibre, 
  • moisture, 
  • vitamins such as: 
  • linolieic acid, 
  • zinc, 
  • vitamin E, 
  • niacin, 
  • ascorbic acid, 
  • biotin, 
  • omega 6, 
  • omega 3, 
  • calcium, 
  • phosphorous etc.  

This analysis is needed to be shown for the AAFCO (association of american feed control officials) dog food nutrient profile.



The food should be free from artificial flavour, colour, low in salt and low in preservatives.



Look At The Quality Of The Ingredients

The AAFCO (the governing body for the feed industry) do not allow dog food manufacturers to to list the quality of their ingredients on the packaging (ex. human grade food or not).


If you want to know the quality of the dog food ingredients, more in depth research needs to be done. This is very time consuming. The Petsumer Reportlooks into the quality of the ingredients to know if they're human grade or not.


Don't Be Afraid To Question The Manufacturer

You should do your homework by reading anything you can about the manufacturer of a particular dog food you are interested in buying when doing dry dog food comparison shopping.

DO not be afraid to call up the manufacturer and see if you can talk to a real person.


Other things to look for when doing dry dog food comparison?


How much should you feed your dog?

The dog food should also have a table with the dogs weight and daily intake of food per cup.


Satisfaction guarantee.   If they list a phone number, they stand behind their product.


Expiry date - check that the food is before the expiry date.



A final note:

If your dog wont eat the food, then maybe there is something wrong with the food, or they just don't like it.  They have tastebuds too.  If they dont like it, find something else.

Every dog is different.  If the food isn't agreeing with the dogs digestive system, try a something different.  First buy a smaller bag of quality food that says 'for sensitive stomachs'.  Always, change the new food gradually with the current food mixed together over a few days.  Give the new food at least one week so your doggy's tummy can adjust.  If it still doesn't agree, try one more food, or take your pooch to the vet. 

If your dog continues to have troubles try some quality name brands that offer dog foods for sensitive stomachs.  Choose the food using the dry dog food comparison guidelines above and also the 

Petsumer Report for additional information.






Petsumer Report more in depth research of the quality dog food ingredients and 1-5 paw ratings of most dog foods.


Return To Dog Food Allergies From Dry Dog Food Comparison


Return To Natural Dog Food


Return To Home



If you liked this article, please share it on: del.icio.us, StumbleUpon or Digg. Or another favourite website or social media such as Facebook, pintrest or twitter. Or tell your other dog friends! Thank you.

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.


Popular Pages

Our Recommended Dog Toys


small dog breeds

Stop Barking Today



Free E-books